Tomek wrote:Gomisan wrote:http://lmgtfy.com/?q=is+thermal+paste+carcinogenic#
Before making claims that something is a carcinogen, you really should at least take the time to verify such a claim.
It 'may' be that some pastes have contained known carcinogens, but as with anything you use you should be able to get an MSDS and use it appropriately.
AFAIK, most thermal pastes these days use silver and silicon. Possibly older Beryllium based substances were toxic to a degree, but I don't think they use it anymore.
So really, don't believe every tale someone tells on the internet.
(I'd be more worried about the fumes from printing and acetone we all use!)
Hi Gomisan,
I'm not just intentionally willy-nilly repeating things from the internet - I'm basing this off of the words I was told at a past summer-job while I was a solder&assembly minion. I should have gone off with a disclaimer that the higher quality pastes- any that you buy off shelf- are likely to be more friendly, but that I would suspect the cheap as dirt paste you can buy off DX and similar mainland based sellers is more likely to be toxic if the toxic preparation is cheaper. And I suppose I am interchanging carcinogenic and toxic which are not the same thing, but hey, I'm just trying to get a mild point across and wasn't intending to go for the "everything will kill you" line. Instead, I mean that if you're going to interact frequently with the paste, as I would, because I have magnet mounted glass plate that I switch out frequently, then you might want to be aware if the paste is carcinogenic or not or that it has a chance of being the kind that is.
I can see how you're irritated but give me a break, when we store things in our mind as fact we don't always double check that fact. I appreciate you calling me out this time so I know better in the future.
And, even if paste is bad, if you're not interacting with it frequently then I would not worry so much. But I started off printing thinking "of the fumes and acetone won't kill me" but it's been a year and so I've recently worked hard to reduce my exposure because it's clearly not one-off exposure.
I too work in the computer industry and I've been in contact with Thermal grease/paste for years, and I still have all my hair (although I can't make the same claim about my brain cells).
Anyway, this entire "thermal paste is carcinogenic" stuff has been passed around for years and to this day no one has yet to prove long term ill effects of being in contact with thermal compounds. So most of us in the business refer to this as an "urban myth".
Most of this got started when someone found out that in some extremely specialized application, thermal paste containing Beryllium Oxide was used. Beryllium oxide can cause beryllium disease (a form of lung cancer) if inhaled as a powder/dust, so in some cases where BeO exists in powder form, or ceramics or solid BeO is likely to be sanded caution should be taken to prevent inhalation.
However in the average application (or the average use of thermal paste compounds), this is not an issue since the BeO would not be present in a powder form. Additionally, BeO is very expensive, so it's not commonly used in consumer grade thermal paste, rather it's used in chip manufacturing.
Does this mean I would spread this stuff on 64 square inches with my bare fingers, probably not, but not because I'd be afraid, but because it would be really messy.
To print or, 3D print, that is the question...
SD3 printer w/too many mods, Printrbot Simple Maker Ed., FormLabs Form 1+
AnyCubic Photon, Shining 3D EinScan-S & Atlas 3D scanners...
...and too much time on my hands.
