26

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

proctor_richard wrote:

they used the money to pay for the development

Are you just presenting speculation as truth or do you have some sort of proof?


I believe Solidoodle severely underestimated the costs and timelines associated with going the custom fabricated parts and mass production route.  I think they have also failed to foster the maker community good will by not providing routine updates and sneak peaks through social media and blogs that we've come to expect from maker companies.  Their uninformed/empowered support has only compounded people's frustrations.

From my perspective, Solidoodle is going through growth pains that all companies go through in rapidly changing industries.  this might even be their make or break moment.  It all depends on the quality of the product that they're shipping.

This is not unlike the computer revolution in the 80s, the whole industry is proliferated with fledgling start-ups trying to act like large established companies.  And you've got companies like Stratsys and  3DSystems who are looking much like IBM and DEC did back then.   A lot of these companies are going to fail, some will go on to be the next Apples, Microsofts, and Dells of the 3d printer world.  I find it all fascinating and while I've been anxious to get a 3d printer and start making stuff, I've also been enjoying the chaos because it reminds me so much of what happened in the 80s.

27 (edited by redbarret 2015-01-15 20:40:21)

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

Jagowilson, I've always admired your "never give up" attitude and willingness to help. You've also helped me quite a bit and I'm thankful for that.
But I'm afraid I'll have to disagree with your post. If we were talking over pm or email, I wouldn't see a point to argue about this, but there are others in this forum who I don't agree have to go through all that trouble we have.
So sorry, but I'll have to respond to all you said and sorry if it will seem harsh, it's just my honest opinion...

But first about the chargeback thing,

jagowilson wrote:

You realize most banks sign a contract with Visa that explicitly forbids the use of chargebacks, right?

Never had problem with chargebacks. Any source?

And most credit card companies only protect purchases to s set amount, usually $300-$500.

Any source for this too?

And you do know besides chargebacks many countries also have actual laws that are legally binding that allow you to demand refund for certain items for certain duration of time, or at the very least agencies that receive feedback from customers and pressure companies to act better, like the ones I linked?

If you want your money's worth, either fix the machine or sell it someone who can.
You may not like this response, but I fail to see how you have any other options.

I just listed some options...

Complaining on here is not making any machines work and I think the entire concept behind this thread goes against a lot of what this community stands for.

Complaining here allows

1) Newcomers who are considering to get a Solidoodle to have a clearer picture of what they are getting into.
I only wish there was such a topic when I first learned about Solidoodle. I wouldn't have a Solidoodle now, wouldn't have wasted so much time and experienced so much frustration, needlessly.

2) Just having somewhere for people to express their frustration and release the heat...

I love bashing SD's poor decisions all day but I will not back the anti-upgrade sentiment emerging like a cancer in this thread.

And I'll say the same about the pro-upgrade opinions.

Look, first of all, if you're gonna fix the issues of your product instead of pressuring the company to make better quality products in the first place, they're not going to change the quality of their products.

If you aren't ingenious enough to fix the machine, are you ingenious enough to actually make anything useful with your printer?

And I strongly disagree here.
Someone close to me got an Ultimaker 2 recently. Worked out of the box with no issues. No problems since. Will he need to learn some internals when something gets damaged, etc? Until there is something like a repair service for 3d printers, Yes. But when will that happen? And how much will he need to learn if say he needs to replace his extruder motor? Obviously not take apart the whole machine and learn all that electronics and mechanics and do hours of testing, trial and error like we had to.

This is like saying if you don't know how your PC works, you can't make something good out of it...

3d designers use 3d printers.
Architects do.
These are artistic people, most of them don't know electronics, programming, engineering...
Heck, even people with no 3d skills download STL models from Thingiverse or similar and print useful or useless stuff they want to.

I understand where you're coming from. Until 3d printers are more mainstream and mass produced, the failure rate is going to be high and you're going to have to know low-level stuff to maintain it, but unlike few years ago now there are (expensive) 3d printers that have low failure rate, easy software and (so) *not* targeted and tinkerers. This is what Sam Servantes wanted Solidoodle Press to be too and looks like it failed.
"Targeted at mainstream consumers" by his own words, quoted from here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CkZCgX2WOuc
And people who bought it expected that too. Most are not going to fix it either because they know there is no need to do all that for getting a 3d printer to work, by just looking at other 3d printers, or simply because they can't.
And there's nothing we can do to change that obviously.

And lets be honest, even most of us "tinkerers" haven't gotten our printers to work "perfectly" after months of tinkering. I just read someone already seeing issues with the "direct drive" mod everyone is talking about recently.

So suggesting newcomers who bought a "plug and play" machine and likely don't have much technical knowledge to upgrade or fix it when some of us "tinkerers" haven't been able to even fix ours completely is just bad advice to me and suggesting them to spare their money and time while they can isn't...

Solidoodle 4

28

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

redbarret wrote:

Someone close to me got an Ultimaker 2 recently. Worked out of the box with no issues. No problems since. Will he need to learn some internals when something gets damaged, etc? Until there is something like a repair service for 3d printers, Yes. But when will that happen? And how much will he need to learn if say he needs to replace his extruder motor? Obviously not take apart the whole machine and learn all that electronics and mechanics and do hours of testing, trial and error like we had to.

What!

An Ultimaker 2 costs 5 times as much as a Solidoodle.

This is like saying your buddy has a Ferrari, so Ford sucks for making something that can't go 0-60 in 3 seconds.

29 (edited by redbarret 2015-01-15 20:19:14)

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

If Ford claimed to buyers to have the same features of a Ferrari, then that would be a good analogy.
Lower price wouldn't be an excuse...

Solidoodle 4

30

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

redbarret wrote:

If Ford claimed to buyers to have the same features of a Ferrari, then that would be a good analogy.
Lower price wouldn't be an excuse...

exactly! they sold this as a plug and play right out of the box. im tired of this with SD. if my press doesnt work right of box i will be leniant and give them 1 issue. after that i dont care if its a loose grub screw on the extruder stepper they can have the thing back with a full (+ shipping ) refund or ill take it to the better business people.

when you sell it as a product to tinkerers i expect to tinker.
when you sell it as out og box i expect out of box

SD2 - mirror bed - e3d v6 - extruder cooling fan - no enclosure.

31

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

Great - then if they're the same to you, why didn't you buy the Utilimaker? Right. Because it is 5 times more.

Somehow you expect to pay 1/5th the price, and get the same results WITH THE SAME AMOUNT OF EFFORT...?

You can't get something for nothing. Solidoodle is cheaper, the build quality and quality control are going to be worse. My analogy holds. If you don't like it, cancel the order. If you don't cancel the order, stop complaining.

32

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

redbarret wrote:

If Ford claimed to buyers to have the same features of a Ferrari, then that would be a good analogy.
Lower price wouldn't be an excuse...

Solidoodle isn't claiming to have the same features as Utilimaker. They aren't claiming to have the same quality control. It is foolish to think otherwise, considering the price difference. Ford might say they have great ride quality, but I wouldn't expect the comfort of a Lexus. For one to claim they expect Utilimaker quality at 1/5th the price, they would have to be disingenuous.

It is the VERY FIRST SHIPMENT of a product that is a LOT cheaper than what you're comparing it to. And you think the comparison is fair?

Most of these folks got their printer for $349. You can't buy an assembled printer for $349 anywhere. It is literally so cheap there isn't anything to compare it to!

33 (edited by redbarret 2015-01-15 23:44:17)

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

elmoret wrote:

Solidoodle isn't claiming to have the same features as Utilimaker.

I'm not saying they are claiming to have all the "same features", but one feature: being "plug-and-play".
And once again, price is totally irrelevant. Some people bought it for feature A and it doesn't have it.

That's like saying sure this Ford isn't as fast as Ferrari but for this price you can't find anything better anyway, so it doesn't matter if Ford has lied about it and you didn't get what you payed for.

I also mentioned Ultimaker because of claims in this thread that printers shouldn't be advertised as plug-and-play because they aren't. I argue that some are actually.

Solidoodle 4

34

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

so i cant expect a quality.. functioning printer for 600 GBP ( incl shipping + import)..

xyz is less...is farely stable
printrbot simple metal = has won awards from make magazine and costs around same as press.

they are yet to be released but the new matter mod-t as released demonstration videos and has some genuine innovation in it.

i originally placed order for multiple presses in hopes of running my own fdm service for local schools.

sam has quite effectively shat upon that dream

SD2 - mirror bed - e3d v6 - extruder cooling fan - no enclosure.

35

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

That's a little personal there. I'm miffed at him, but let's give them a little time to get their house in order.

I'm suprised they didn't test at least 25 of them off the boat before shipping them. Mine had broken filament jammed in the extruded and a misaligned extruder. It's obvious that there guys get a rough ride from China.

They need to hire someone that is maniacally focused on Quality Aaurance.

36

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

I'm suprised they didn't test at least 25 of them off the boat before shipping them.

They should have had them all shipped to Brooklyn for QC and maybe caught the wire interference issue, noticed that the factory wasn't getting the set screws tight enough on extruder gears.  Instead they listened to all those customers who couldn't bear to wait another day and shipped them straight from the port.

37

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

Ian -- maybe we're partially to blame then. but 4 months late... is 4 months late.
Communication on a US test plan for the first shipment would have helped soothe it.

38

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

The real mistake was announcing and offering them for sale when they did.  This week should have been the first we heard about the Press.  They could have teased, or had blog posts about development along the way.  The worst that would have happened was being accused of vaporware.  I don't know if the preorders were the only option for financing the tooling costs, but it was probably the cheapest, though it cost a lot in reputation.

I don't how they are managing the SD4, Apprentice and Workstation at the same time in the tiny space that they have.  Here is the street view of their address - https://www.google.com/maps/place/Solid … 59!6m1!1e1

The factory floor is maybe 20ftx40ft, and that includes the print farm and a corner for shipping.  I would be nervous if I was an assembler there.  I think they will be faced with the choice of making the other models overseas or moving to a bigger space.

39

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

is there a pool yet for how long till we can buy a refurbished Press for a couple hundred bucks? ;^P

Solidoodle 2 with Deluxe kit cover & glass bed with heater. and 2nd board SD2 used not 3rd and alum platform not installed yet still wood. also need cooling fan installed to board. use Repetier Host couple vers. Slic3r also have all free ware STL programs

40

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

I would imagine that sitting in a shipping container for that long didn't help with the moisture content of the test filament.  That's my guess for the sudden rise in Press extruder issues.

Printit Industries Model 8.10 fully enclosed CoreXY, Chamber heat
3-SD3's & a Workbench all fully enclosed, RH-Slic3r Win7pro, E3D V6, Volcano & Cyclops Hot End
SSR/500W AC Heated Glass Bed, Linear bearings on SS rods. Direct Drive Y-axis, BulldogXL
Thanks to all for your contributions

41

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

IanJohnson wrote:

I don't how they are managing the SD4, Apprentice and Workstation at the same time in the tiny space that they have.  Here is the street view of their address - https://www.google.com/maps/place/Solid … 59!6m1!1e1

The factory floor is maybe 20ftx40ft, and that includes the print farm and a corner for shipping.  I would be nervous if I was an assembler there.  I think they will be faced with the choice of making the other models overseas or moving to a bigger space.

Wow, that's really small. I have more than 800sqft!

42

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

To calm the haters:

http://imgur.com/a/TdhqU

Press is definitely capable of the "plug and play" they promised... they just have some quality control issues to figure out.

43

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

proctor_richard wrote:

so i cant expect a quality.. functioning printer for 600 GBP ( incl shipping + import)..

xyz is less...is farely stable
printrbot simple metal = has won awards from make magazine and costs around same as press.

they are yet to be released but the new matter mod-t as released demonstration videos and has some genuine innovation in it

Printrbot Simple Metal is $600. These press preorders were $349. Almost double is not "around the same price".

The Press also has a much larger build volume, a heated bed, supports ABS.

Not comparable.

44

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

elmoret wrote:

To calm the haters:

http://imgur.com/a/TdhqU

Press is definitely capable of the "plug and play" they promised... they just have some quality control issues to figure out.

thats just low poly models

Solidoodle 2 with Deluxe kit cover & glass bed with heater. and 2nd board SD2 used not 3rd and alum platform not installed yet still wood. also need cooling fan installed to board. use Repetier Host couple vers. Slic3r also have all free ware STL programs

45

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

ill be holding off further comment until my deadline for my tracking number passes. It will be interesting to see what the press is capable of once it has competent software. I fully intent to use simplify3d with the press as well as trying out a machine control processor from another company.

SD2 - mirror bed - e3d v6 - extruder cooling fan - no enclosure.

46 (edited by redbarret 2015-01-16 09:40:40)

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

One last thing:
The photos of SDP prints do not definitely calm us "haters" down.
As n2ri said, they are lowpoly models with sharp corners where backlash is not as visible and the printed calibration model photos show clear backlash on the circular hole, good luck fixing that.

And finally, Solidoodle Press being "capable" of "plug and play" is irrelevant.
Right now it isn't "plug and play". Most people who bought it now haven't gotten a "plug and play" device for which they payed for.
Whether it will in the future doesn't matter for the customers who have bought it now.
And that is assuming they do fix some quality control issues which I really doubt looking back but we'll need to wait and see.

Call me a hater, but some who posted here are customers who have bought a faulty product, being labeled a hater after sharing their furstration here in the most popular Solidoodle community is going to distance them even more from this company.

That's all.

Solidoodle 4

47

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

redbarret wrote:

One last thing:
The photos of SDP prints do not definitely calm us "haters" down.
As n2ri said, they are lowpoly models with sharp corners where backlash is not as visible and the printed calibration model photos show clear backlash on the circular hole, good luck fixing that.

And finally, Solidoodle Press being "capable" of "plug and play" is irrelevant.
Right now it isn't "plug and play". Most people who bought it now haven't gotten a "plug and play" device for which they payed for.
Whether it will in the future doesn't matter for the customers who have bought it now.
And that is assuming they do fix some quality control issues which I really doubt looking back but we'll need to wait and see.

Call me a hater, but some who posted here are customers who have bought a faulty product, being labeled a hater after sharing their furstration here in the most popular Solidoodle community is going to distance them even more from this company.

That's all.

could not agree more.

if anything i feel that by staying quite we are enabling solidoodle to keep sending out crap products. If they realise that its gonna affect them significantly they might pull there finger out.

SD2 - mirror bed - e3d v6 - extruder cooling fan - no enclosure.

48

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

redbarret wrote:

One last thing:
The photos of SDP prints do not definitely calm us "haters" down.
As n2ri said, they are lowpoly models with sharp corners where backlash is not as visible and the printed calibration model photos show clear backlash on the circular hole, good luck fixing that.

And finally, Solidoodle Press being "capable" of "plug and play" is irrelevant.
Right now it isn't "plug and play". Most people who bought it now haven't gotten a "plug and play" device for which they payed for.
Whether it will in the future doesn't matter for the customers who have bought it now.
And that is assuming they do fix some quality control issues which I really doubt looking back but we'll need to wait and see.

Call me a hater, but some who posted here are customers who have bought a faulty product, being labeled a hater after sharing their furstration here in the most popular Solidoodle community is going to distance them even more from this company.

That's all.

With the exception of broken components most of these printers are plug and play.

The problem is you have a new user base that expects an HP inkjet type of plug and play experience. And this same user base has no more than basic knowledge of 3D printers.

"Plug and play" is somewhat subjective in my mind and considering that 95% of new users can barely run a laser jet properly it's no wonder people are pissed off.

SD2 with E3D, SD Press, Form 1+
Filastruder
NYLON (taulman): http://www.soliforum.com/topic/466/nylon/

49

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

DePartedPrinter wrote:

With the exception of broken components most of these printers are plug and play.

The problem is you have a new user base that expects an HP inkjet type of plug and play experience. And this same user base has no more than basic knowledge of 3D printers.

"Plug and play" is somewhat subjective in my mind and considering that 95% of new users can barely run a laser jet properly it's no wonder people are pissed off.

Ha. If you get a print spooler to cancel or pause a job I could take a few lessons from you tongue

50 (edited by OneMoreCast 2015-01-17 06:16:41)

Re: Solidoodle complaints, problems, wait time bitching etc...share yours

DePartedPrinter wrote:
redbarret wrote:

One last thing:
The photos of SDP prints do not definitely calm us "haters" down.
As n2ri said, they are lowpoly models with sharp corners where backlash is not as visible and the printed calibration model photos show clear backlash on the circular hole, good luck fixing that.

And finally, Solidoodle Press being "capable" of "plug and play" is irrelevant.
Right now it isn't "plug and play". Most people who bought it now haven't gotten a "plug and play" device for which they payed for.
Whether it will in the future doesn't matter for the customers who have bought it now.
And that is assuming they do fix some quality control issues which I really doubt looking back but we'll need to wait and see.

Call me a hater, but some who posted here are customers who have bought a faulty product, being labeled a hater after sharing their furstration here in the most popular Solidoodle community is going to distance them even more from this company.

That's all.

With the exception of broken components most of these printers are plug and play.

The problem is you have a new user base that expects an HP inkjet type of plug and play experience. And this same user base has no more than basic knowledge of 3D printers.

"Plug and play" is somewhat subjective in my mind and considering that 95% of new users can barely run a laser jet properly it's no wonder people are pissed off.

Theres a fine line between calibrating and tinkering...and 4 out of 5 people having to tighten the same screw because QC sucks. Tinkering, modding and calibrating are par for the course (and fun, at least in my experience) having to fix THEIR fuck ups or oversights is more the problem imo

"All your base are belong to us." SD4 with a RUMBA, supernight PS, 40mm fan on X motor, lawsey carriages with new better tolerance rods, flanged rear bearings, new NEMA 17 with leadscrew on Z-Axis, and e3d v6 with MK5.


Ward and Jago are my heroes tongue