501 (edited by Fastrack 2013-01-23 00:14:44)

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

elmoret wrote:
iowacattails wrote:

Can anyone tell me where they think the metal coming from. If the 5/8 bit is .625" and the nipple is approx .635/.645  there is minimally .005" clearance both sides. Is it only from mis-alignment? Are there pipe nipples out there with closer tolerances? On the machines that use 2 nipples supported by back-to-back pipe flanges aligning properly with each other?

I'm not sure either. Here's what I know so far:

Myself - saw contaminant once, when using the version 1 with two flanges in the middle. Never have run clear pellets. Roughly 10kg extruded.
DeParted - has seen quite a bit of contaminant, in both version 1 and version 2. Runs clear pellets. Unknown total extruded.
Ian - Has run natural and clear pellets. No comments of contaminant in version 1, has not run version 2 yet.
Nick - No comments of contaminant in version 1, still waiting on version 2.

I don't know of anyone else that has run their Filastruder yet.

Any point in grinding down the flutes on your auger ?  Are they sharp like a standard drill bit?  I guess a brass nipple would be too soft?

Ben

502 (edited by elmoret 2013-01-23 00:39:03)

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

They are flat with respect to the inner edge of the pipe nipple. Like this:

http://a248.e.akamai.net/origin-cdn.volusion.com/at4hf.fao4d/v/vspfiles/photos/GRN-60A-5-fslash-8-2.jpg

It's hard for me to diagnose the contamination as I'm not seeing any in the filament, and not seeing any wear on the auger surface. Brass would be softer, but I'm not sure how it would wear - chunks or particles.

503

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

where I work we extrude a lot of different materials including  Nylon, PTFE, PVDF & PVDM to name a few.
all our extruders are stainless with a high polish. The nipple we use is rough and the ABS pellets are  abrasive.
I have talked to the Mechanical & Chemical engineers at work and they all say either polish
the pipe ID or go with stainless.

Ultimaker S3.

504

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

dubbsd wrote:

where I work we extrude a lot of different materials including  Nylon, PTFE, PVDF & PVDM to name a few.
all our extruders are stainless with a high polish. The nipple we use is rough and the ABS pellets are  abrasive.
I have talked to the Mechanical & Chemical engineers at work and they all say either polish
the pipe ID or go with stainless.

I polished the inside of the tilt tube on my 1981 outboard (which was about 1' long) and was rusted up.  I took a copper pipe cleaning brush (Oatey Heavy Duty cleaning brush), cut the handle off twisted the metal where the handle was around a 4" nail and soldered them together.   $4 for a cleaning brush instead of $25 for a purpose built "tilt tube clean brush".  It was a very cheap solution and the inside of the tube was super shiny!  I had to clean it from both sides to reach the entire tube of course.

As for the auger, that makes sense!  I know some drill bits have a cutting edge and of course any non-smooth surface inside the nipple would wear off... but you said no auger wear... So I'm at a loss!

Is there anywhere in the process where plastic could get stuck and be forced out later (ie being burned like we see on the end of the nozzles?).  I don't remember reading if the particles were magnetic or not.. maybe I missed that?

Ben

505

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

There's no auger wear on mine, but also no particles. It's difficult for me to troubleshoot the issue. Once I have clear ABS (it's enroute to me) maybe I'll start seeing particles, and then be able to troubleshoot.

I ran the new motor for 6 hours tonight, emptying out the hopper and pipe in preparation for the clear ABS.

I suppose it's possible plastic is getting burned, broken up, and forced out later. Not sure if the particles are magnetic or not.

I have an idea that will get rid of the need to cut the pipe with a dremel, and the new motor shafts don't need dremel work either. That would eliminate the need for a dremel, and make the tools necessary just a drill and simple hand tools.

506 (edited by DePartedPrinter 2013-01-23 07:29:13)

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

dubbsd wrote:

where I work we extrude a lot of different materials including  Nylon, PTFE, PVDF & PVDM to name a few.
all our extruders are stainless with a high polish. The nipple we use is rough and the ABS pellets are  abrasive.
I have talked to the Mechanical & Chemical engineers at work and they all say either polish
the pipe ID or go with stainless.


Yay. We have a winner...my theory all along was the pellets are just to abrasive for the nipple.

Tim, what do you think the chances are I can get my hands on a stainless nipple and coupler?

SD2 with E3D, SD Press, Form 1+
Filastruder
NYLON (taulman): http://www.soliforum.com/topic/466/nylon/

507

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

DeParted, what temp are you running the clear at?  I've been having trouble getting the tolerance under .1mm using the spool winder, and I've been using the clear I got from Ebay.  Just running it to the floor is problematic as well.  It has a higher melt flow index than the natural, so it droops a lot coming out of the die rather than curving out like the natural. 

I'll load the natural up again tomorrow and see if its different.   I ran across a plastics expert on an Answer site and asked a couple of questions - http://www.allexperts.com/user.cgi?m=6& … ID=4910925

He recommended a die 2x the filament size with a land 3x the die diameter (land is the depth of the die).   The plastic would be hauled off at a rate that would stretch it down to the desired diameter.  I'm hoping I can get it to work with the natural.  With the clear I was getting about 13"/min.    I took some video of the roller gear and checked the timing of each rotation and it was pretty constant.  I'm guessing the extrusion rate wasn't consistent, which might have something to do with the clear being less viscous.

508 (edited by elmoret 2013-01-23 14:47:05)

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

IanJohnson wrote:

DeParted, what temp are you running the clear at?  I've been having trouble getting the tolerance under .1mm using the spool winder, and I've been using the clear I got from Ebay.  Just running it to the floor is problematic as well.  It has a higher melt flow index than the natural, so it droops a lot coming out of the die rather than curving out like the natural. 

I'll load the natural up again tomorrow and see if its different.   I ran across a plastics expert on an Answer site and asked a couple of questions - http://www.allexperts.com/user.cgi?m=6& … ID=4910925

He recommended a die 2x the filament size with a land 3x the die diameter (land is the depth of the die).   The plastic would be hauled off at a rate that would stretch it down to the desired diameter.  I'm hoping I can get it to work with the natural.  With the clear I was getting about 13"/min.    I took some video of the roller gear and checked the timing of each rotation and it was pretty constant.  I'm guessing the extrusion rate wasn't consistent, which might have something to do with the clear being less viscous.

Have you tried dropping the temperature? The gray has a different MFI than the natural, and that's how I compensate.

That plastics expert seems to really know his stuff. I can't believe they use a die size 2x the intended diameter!

I'm really becoming a fan of this new motor. Definitely seems quieter, ran all night without getting warm, even though it was wrapped in a thick towel. I want to do a teardown on it, probably later today. If the gearbox and bearings look stronger, it'll be the new pick. It's only $5 more than the other one.

Ian, I saw you were concerned about the rate of extrusion. A couple tips:

1.) back the auger out of the melt zone a little
2.) higher temperatures
3.) you can overvolt the motor, as long as it is not getting warm to the touch.

As a side note, I saw he said 80% of the heat comes from mechanical shear. If the Filastruder relied on that, the motor would have to be 15x more powerful.

509

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

DePartedPrinter wrote:
dubbsd wrote:

where I work we extrude a lot of different materials including  Nylon, PTFE, PVDF & PVDM to name a few.
all our extruders are stainless with a high polish. The nipple we use is rough and the ABS pellets are  abrasive.
I have talked to the Mechanical & Chemical engineers at work and they all say either polish
the pipe ID or go with stainless.


Yay. We have a winner...my theory all along was the pellets are just to abrasive for the nipple.

Tim, what do you think the chances are I can get my hands on a stainless nipple and coupler?

Good question.

Everything at McMaster I can find in Schedule 40 is claimed to have a seam, though the iron pipes I've been getting don't, so maybe the stainless ones won't either.

There are many, many other suppliers of pipe nipples though. I just haven't done a search.

510

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

The clear has a melt flow index of 3.  The natural, if it is PA-747 which is typical, is 1.2.  Injection molding plastics use 5 and up.   I'm thinking that with the runnier clear  there is less back pressure and inconsistencies in the feed to the melt zone are more likely to transmit through to the extrusion.

511

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

I ran the clear down to 145 at which point the motor seemed to start having trouble extruding, and the filament still didn't arch like the natural.  This was with a 1/16 die.  I'm interested in seeing what your experience is when you get your clear pellets.

512

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

IanJohnson wrote:

DeParted, what temp are you running the clear at?

193

SD2 with E3D, SD Press, Form 1+
Filastruder
NYLON (taulman): http://www.soliforum.com/topic/466/nylon/

513 (edited by elmoret 2013-01-23 16:25:50)

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

I've been using this as the natural/white:

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi … 0843294091

SABIC MG94-NA1000

Which is what I've included in all the beta kits.

The MFR is listed as:
Melt Flow Rate, 220°C/5.0 kg: 12g/10 min ISO 1133 Standards
Melt Flow Rate, 220°C/10.0 kg: 42g/10 min ISO 1133 Standards

Ian, the clear you linked me to is PA-758, which has the following MF properties:

Melt Flow,  220°C/10.0 kg: 34g/10 min ISO 1133 Standards

Not sure how that relates to the MFI you were citing, but it actually seems like the clear should be less "runny", unless I'm reading these sheets wrong.

EDIT: Ah - the MFI you were citing is ASTM D-1238 --- 200°C, 5kg mass placed on top. Just different standards.

514

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

IanJohnson wrote:

I ran the clear down to 145 at which point the motor seemed to start having trouble extruding, and the filament still didn't arch like the natural.  This was with a 1/16 die.  I'm interested in seeing what your experience is when you get your clear pellets.


Ian, how much clear have you run so far? have you seen any contaminates yet?

SD2 with E3D, SD Press, Form 1+
Filastruder
NYLON (taulman): http://www.soliforum.com/topic/466/nylon/

515

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

DePartedPrinter wrote:

stainless nipple and coupler?

http://www.amazon.com/dp/B004XEKNF6/ref … xHash=true

It's hard to say how much better, if any, stainless would be over the nipples we have. I have no idea what alloy is used in the nipples we're currently using, which makes it impossible to compare hardness. 304 stainless is definitely not the hardest stainless alloy, in fact it's one of the softer ones. I can't find nipples in anything other than 304/316, probably since hardness isn't a big factor in transporting fluids.

I will say you could probably get away with a 5 or 6 inch nipple if you use stainless, as it's coefficient of thermal conductivity is about 1/5th that of iron/regular steel. You will have to either shorten the auger or backspace it with washers/more spacers on the thrust bearing mount if you use a shorter nipple.

516 (edited by elmoret 2013-01-23 17:02:07)

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

You could skip having to cut the nipple with a hotend like this:

brass cap - coupler - 4" nipple - t fitting - 2" nipple - flange

And use the t fitting for a hopper. No more need for a dremel, but I haven't tested it yet.

517

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

DeParted, do you have a good magnifine glass and strong magnet?  Have you checked to see if the contaminates are ferromagnetic?

518

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

Has anyone else besides Ian, Blake, and Nick gotten up and running yet?

519

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

I've seen a speck here and there in the filament, but I haven't run it long enough at a stretch to rule out left over filings from drilling the nozzle.  One source might be burnt plastic.  The corner between the inside of the plug and the inner wall of the coupling is a place where plastic can get trapped and cook for awhile.  Normally extruders have a smooth funnel from the ID of the barrel to the die so there isn't any place the plastic can get trapped.  The plug I have on now is drilled in steps from 1/2" down to the 1/16" hole which extends for just over 1/2".  It isn't completely smooth, there are some small steps between drill sizes and 1/2" doesn't cover the full diameter of the inside face.

520

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

New motor internals look good:

https://dl.dropbox.com/u/1786359/Photo%20Jan%2023%2C%201%2005%2019%20PM.jpg

The internals are definitely beefier than the Beta v1 and v2 motor. The output shaft bearings are longer, and the tooth width internal to the box is wider. I think it's a better fit for our uses. Not much more expensive.

521

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

elmoret wrote:

Has anyone else besides Ian, Blake, and Nick gotten up and running yet?


I am extruding but haven't dialed in the diameter.  I am also seeing contamination but have only run about 1.5 hours.




Jason

522

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

Jason wrote:
elmoret wrote:

Has anyone else besides Ian, Blake, and Nick gotten up and running yet?

I am extruding but haven't dialed in the diameter.  I am also seeing contamination but have only run about 1.5 hours.

Clear or natural pellets?

523

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

I think I found some 40 micron filters that will work with our design. Cost would be about $3 each. Gonna order some and test.

524

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

How would they be supported?  The industrial extruders use a perforated plate to hold the filter against the pressure of the plastic.

525

Re: Filament Extruder - Convert pellets to filament

I've been looking at McMaster Part 9446T32. They're sintered steel - kinda like a sponge. Not mesh - that won't work.

0.063" thick is 1.6mm, which I think will be fine under pressure. Even at 150psi, that's only 29lbs of force on a 1/2" diameter filter. What I'm picturing then, is this:

https://dl.dropbox.com/u/1786359/nozzleprotopng.png

If 29lbs of force is too much to be supported by the edges of that filter, then I could bore the inset flat with a endmill.