1 (edited by mdrVB6 2015-05-25 23:13:29)

Topic: Colorfabb XT-CF20 quick review

So I grabbed a sample of Colorfabb's XT-CF20 when I was placing an order from printedsolid.  I was interested in trying it out since I had not really heard of this XT filament before.  My understanding is that XT is a type of polyester and this has 20% carbon fiber filaments mixed in.   I printed it on an E3D V6 with no nozzle fan, although if I get one setup I will see if it makes any different (it probably won't except on small layers).  They say that the carbon fiber can be abrasive and wear out your nozzles faster but I only have a little sample to see how I liked it so I didn't see the need to invest in a stainless steel nozzle just yet.  They are somewhat pricey, about $25 each. 

I printed it at 245 C hot end and 60 C heated bed as recommended.  It had absolutely no warping, stuck very well to the build plate, and no layer delamination, even when printed at with the case open.  I just printed a carabiner and a box to test it out and both are very solid feeling.  The density of this is given as 1.37 g/cm3 which is noticably denser than ABS at about 1.0 g/cm3.  The printed parts are very rigid, but I did print fairly thick objects.  The filament itself is fairly brittle prior to printing, I snapped it in one spot trying to get it onto the spool but if you buy a whole spool you won't have to worry about this.

Similar to the various filled PLA filaments available, I have to assume it is not any stronger than plain XT filament.  I would really be interested in a lab test to find the tensile and comprehensive strengths of the printed parts.  Based only on my visual evaluation and touching it, I feel that it might be stronger than ABS.  If any has access to the lab equipment, PM me and I'll send you some part samples to destructively test.

I don't have any pictures because honestly, it looks just like a matte PLA or ABS filament in pictures.  The texture of the finished part is very nice and even a lay person could probably identify it as carbon fiber based.  It is a fairly expensive filament, printedsolid has it for $70 for 750 grams and keep in mind because of the density it will be less length than you are expecting.  Doing a little math, you can see it comes out to 412% the cost of ABS when measured per cm3 (assume $31/ kg for octave ABS on amazon).  Also factor in a new stainless steel nozzle or 2 and you are looking at about $100 to really get into printing this stuff.

You won't be disappointed in the strength, the texture is very satisfying, and it is easy to print.  I might make some bezels or cases out of it and if you were into such a thing... it could make a pretty cool liberator pistol to hang on the shelf and show your buddies.  If you're not worried about the cost, I would say give it a try and you will have one more material to impress your non-printing friends and family.

SD4 w/ RUMBA, E3D Volcano, all bearings, glass bed

2

Re: Colorfabb XT-CF20 quick review

I took a few pictures.  First one just shows the texture.  Second is comparing it to black abs.  Both are at 0.4mm layers.

http://i.imgur.com/KB2oZMM.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/z4r1Zqi.jpg

SD4 w/ RUMBA, E3D Volcano, all bearings, glass bed