<![CDATA[SoliForum - 3D Printing Community — Help with print issues between Cura and Slic3r Engines.]]> https://www.soliforum.com/topic/10942/help-with-print-issues-between-cura-and-slic3r-engines/ Thu, 30 Apr 2015 00:23:18 +0000 PunBB <![CDATA[Re: Help with print issues between Cura and Slic3r Engines.]]> https://www.soliforum.com/post/94459/#p94459 I updated the first post with new info I found.

]]> Thu, 30 Apr 2015 00:23:18 +0000 https://www.soliforum.com/post/94459/#p94459 <![CDATA[Help with print issues between Cura and Slic3r Engines.]]> https://www.soliforum.com/post/94329/#p94329 I got the Da Rampi set up pretty well running on Repetier Host and Marlin firmware. I prefer Cura Host however as it seems do do a better finish in my opinion. I used pretty much the same settings as I used in Rep host and it's Slic3r and I get what you see in the picture.

These are supposed to be 20mm cal cubes with a 20% fill.

So after some more esploring and testing. It now looks like Repetier Host with Slic3r is over extruding becuase my corners are higher than the walls during the print and it seems that Cura with Cura is majorly under extruding as seen in the image..


I have attached what I belive is the first layer Gcode from each slicer and there are some big differences even though the settings to my knowledge are similar. I will have to go back and look at each setting in both slicers.

First Layer Gcode from Cura:

M106 S255                    
G0 X100.61 Y119.30 Z0.60            
G0 X100.30 Y119.70                
G1 F1380 X100.30 Y100.30 E117.93715    
G1 X119.70 Y100.30 E118.63959        
G1 X119.70 Y119.70 E119.34202
G1 X100.30 Y119.70 E120.04446
G0 F9000 X100.70 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y100.70 E121.00639
G0 F9000 X118.83 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y118.83 E121.94471
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y117.98
G1 F1380 X117.99 Y100.51 E122.83959
G0 F9000 X117.14 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y117.14 E123.69101
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y116.29
G1 F1380 X116.29 Y100.51 E124.49899
G0 F9000 X115.44 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y115.44 E125.26352
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y114.59
G1 F1380 X114.59 Y100.51 E125.98461
G0 F9000 X113.74 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y113.74 E126.66224
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y112.89
G1 F1380 X112.89 Y100.51 E127.29643
G0 F9000 X112.05 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y112.05 E127.88716
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y111.20
G1 F1380 X111.20 Y100.51 E128.43445
G0 F9000 X110.35 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y110.35 E128.93827
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y109.50
G1 F1380 X109.50 Y100.51 E129.39866
G0 F9000 X108.65 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y108.65 E129.81558
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y107.80
G1 F1380 X107.80 Y100.51 E130.18908
G0 F9000 X106.95 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y106.95 E130.51910
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y106.11
G1 F1380 X106.11 Y100.51 E130.80570
G0 F9000 X105.26 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y105.26 E131.04882
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y104.41
G1 F1380 X104.41 Y100.51 E131.24850
G0 F9000 X103.56 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y103.56 E131.40473
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y102.71
G1 F1380 X102.71 Y100.51 E131.51751
G0 F9000 X101.86 Y100.51
G1 F1380 X100.51 Y101.86 E131.58684
G0 F9000 X100.51 Y101.02
G1 F1380 X101.02 Y100.51 E131.61273
G0 F9000 X101.02 Y100.70
G0 X119.30 Y101.55
G0 X119.49 Y101.55
G1 F1380 X101.55 Y119.49 E132.53124
G0 F9000 X102.40 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y102.40 E133.40627
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y103.25
G1 F1380 X103.25 Y119.49 E134.23788
G0 F9000 X104.10 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y104.10 E135.02601
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y104.95
G1 F1380 X104.94 Y119.49 E135.77073
G0 F9000 X105.79 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y105.80 E136.47197
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y106.64
G1 F1380 X106.64 Y119.49 E137.12976
G0 F9000 X107.49 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y107.49 E137.74410
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y108.34
G1 F1380 X108.34 Y119.49 E138.31500
G0 F9000 X109.19 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y109.19 E138.84245
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y110.04
G1 F1380 X110.04 Y119.49 E139.32644
G0 F9000 X110.89 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y110.89 E139.76699
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y111.73
G1 F1380 X111.73 Y119.49 E140.16410
G0 F9000 X112.58 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y112.58 E140.51775
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y113.43
G1 F1380 X113.43 Y119.49 E140.82796
G0 F9000 X114.28 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y114.28 E141.09471
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y115.13
G1 F1380 X115.13 Y119.49 E141.31800
G0 F9000 X115.98 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y115.98 E141.49786
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y116.83
G1 F1380 X116.83 Y119.49 E141.63425
G0 F9000 X117.67 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y117.67 E141.72721
G0 F9000 X119.49 Y118.52
G1 F1380 X118.52 Y119.49 E141.77670
G0 F9000 X119.37 Y119.49
G1 F1380 X119.49 Y119.37 E141.78277
G0 F9000 X119.30 Y119.37
G0 X118.20 Y118.20

First Layer Gcode from RH with Slic3r:

M106 S89                    
G1 F4200.000 E49.69507            
G92 E0                        
G1 Z0.600 F9000.000                
G1 X118.835 Y118.835 F9000.000        
G1 E6.00000 F4200.000            
G1 X101.165 Y118.835 E7.00171 F2400.000    
G1 X101.165 Y101.165 E8.00341        
G1 X118.835 Y101.165 E9.00512        
G1 X118.835 Y118.775 E10.00343
G1 X119.298 Y119.298 F9000.000
G1 X100.702 Y119.298 E11.05761 F2400.000
G1 X100.702 Y100.702 E12.11179
G1 X119.298 Y100.702 E13.16598
G1 X119.298 Y119.238 E14.21676
G1 X119.761 Y119.761 F9000.000
G1 X100.239 Y119.761 E15.32342 F1800.000
G1 X100.239 Y100.239 E16.43008
G1 X119.761 Y100.239 E17.53674
G1 X119.761 Y119.701 E18.64000
G1 X119.414 Y119.561 F9000.000
G1 X118.519 Y118.479 F9000.000
G1 X118.479 Y118.519 E18.64321 F2400.000
G1 X117.813 Y118.519 E18.68100
G1 X118.519 Y117.813 E18.73765
G1 X118.519 Y117.146 E18.77544
G1 X117.146 Y118.519 E18.88553
G1 X116.479 Y118.519 E18.92332
G1 X118.519 Y116.479 E19.08686
G1 X118.519 Y115.813 E19.12466
G1 X115.813 Y118.519 E19.34164
G1 X115.146 Y118.519 E19.37943
G1 X118.519 Y115.146 E19.64986
G1 X118.519 Y114.480 E19.68765
G1 X114.480 Y118.519 E20.01152
G1 X113.813 Y118.519 E20.04931
G1 X118.519 Y113.813 E20.42663
G1 X118.519 Y113.146 E20.46442
G1 X113.146 Y118.519 E20.89518
G1 X112.480 Y118.519 E20.93297
G1 X118.519 Y112.480 E21.41717
G1 X118.519 Y111.813 E21.45497
G1 X111.813 Y118.519 E21.99261
G1 X111.147 Y118.519 E22.03041
G1 X118.519 Y111.147 E22.62150
G1 X118.519 Y110.480 E22.65929
G1 X110.480 Y118.519 E23.30383
G1 X109.813 Y118.519 E23.34162
G1 X118.519 Y109.813 E24.03960
G1 X118.519 Y109.147 E24.07739
G1 X109.147 Y118.519 E24.82882
G1 X108.480 Y118.519 E24.86661
G1 X118.519 Y108.480 E25.67148
G1 X118.519 Y107.814 E25.70927
G1 X107.814 Y118.519 E26.56758
G1 X107.147 Y118.519 E26.60537
G1 X118.519 Y107.147 E27.51713
G1 X118.519 Y106.480 E27.55492
G1 X106.480 Y118.519 E28.52012
G1 X105.814 Y118.519 E28.55791
G1 X118.519 Y105.814 E29.57656
G1 X118.519 Y105.147 E29.61435
G1 X105.147 Y118.519 E30.68644
G1 X104.480 Y118.519 E30.72423
G1 X118.519 Y104.480 E31.84977
G1 X118.519 Y103.814 E31.88756
G1 X103.814 Y118.519 E33.06654
G1 X103.147 Y118.519 E33.10433
G1 X118.519 Y103.147 E34.33675
G1 X118.519 Y102.481 E34.37454
G1 X102.481 Y118.519 E35.66041
G1 X101.814 Y118.519 E35.69820
G1 X118.519 Y101.814 E37.03751
G1 X118.186 Y101.481 E37.06424
G1 X101.481 Y118.186 E38.40355
G1 X101.481 Y117.519 E38.44134
G1 X117.519 Y101.481 E39.72721
G1 X116.853 Y101.481 E39.76500
G1 X101.481 Y116.853 E40.99742
G1 X101.481 Y116.186 E41.03521
G1 X116.186 Y101.481 E42.21419
G1 X115.520 Y101.481 E42.25198
G1 X101.481 Y115.520 E43.37752
G1 X101.481 Y114.853 E43.41531
G1 X114.853 Y101.481 E44.48740
G1 X114.186 Y101.481 E44.52519
G1 X101.481 Y114.186 E45.54383
G1 X101.481 Y113.520 E45.58162
G1 X113.520 Y101.481 E46.54683
G1 X112.853 Y101.481 E46.58462
G1 X101.481 Y112.853 E47.49638
G1 X101.481 Y112.186 E47.53417
G1 X112.186 Y101.481 E48.39248
G1 X111.520 Y101.481 E48.43027
G1 X101.481 Y111.520 E49.23514
G1 X101.481 Y110.853 E49.27293
G1 X110.853 Y101.481 E50.02436
G1 X110.187 Y101.481 E50.06215
G1 X101.481 Y110.187 E50.76013
G1 X101.481 Y109.520 E50.79792
G1 X109.520 Y101.481 E51.44246
G1 X108.853 Y101.481 E51.48025
G1 X101.481 Y108.853 E52.07134
G1 X101.481 Y108.187 E52.10913
G1 X108.187 Y101.481 E52.64678
G1 X107.520 Y101.481 E52.68457
G1 X101.481 Y107.520 E53.16878
G1 X101.481 Y106.854 E53.20657
G1 X106.854 Y101.481 E53.63733
G1 X106.187 Y101.481 E53.67512
G1 X101.481 Y106.187 E54.05243
G1 X101.481 Y105.520 E54.09022
G1 X105.520 Y101.481 E54.41410
G1 X104.854 Y101.481 E54.45189
G1 X101.481 Y104.854 E54.72232
G1 X101.481 Y104.187 E54.76011
G1 X104.187 Y101.481 E54.97709
G1 X103.521 Y101.481 E55.01488
G1 X101.481 Y103.521 E55.17842
G1 X101.481 Y102.854 E55.21621
G1 X102.854 Y101.481 E55.32631
G1 X102.187 Y101.481 E55.36410
G1 X101.481 Y102.187 E55.42075
G1 X101.481 Y101.521 E55.45854
G1 X101.521 Y101.481 E55.46175
G1 F4200.000 E49.46175
G92 E0

As near as I can tell Cura is pushing out about .4mm less filament per pass than Slic3r is. It also looks like Slic3r is laying filament down at a higher speed. So why Slic3r is over extruding and Cura is under extruding has me baffled. I have never had this much trouble setting up a printer.

]]> Tue, 28 Apr 2015 06:20:32 +0000 https://www.soliforum.com/post/94329/#p94329