51

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

I own a Plastic Scribbler too.  I'd like to chime in on a few things. 

You were asking about the profile layer heights.   If the lead screws in the machine are metric then whole numbers make sense.  The layer height is optimized for english lead screws, but I think the 2100 changed to metric so you might want to check the manufacturer. 

The other item is have you tried hair spray to help with the adhesion?  It can work wonders on making parts stick.   I recommend the Aquanet brand.

52 (edited by stevea3342 2014-10-28 01:36:51)

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

I tried to print the 2d cube, but I don't think I did it right because it printed in 4 passes. Do I need to change the layer height in slic3r to .4 mm also?

<edit>  I'm trying to follow along here:  https://solidoodletips.wordpress.com/20 … flow-rate/

Plastic Scribbler 2100

53

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Things have gotten a little better.   Thanks wardjr for pointing me towards the multiplier problem and the heat.  I found I was getting .49mm, and with a new multiplier I am getting .42 and printed items look much better.  The cone tip looks much better printing at 245, the tip of the cone is not melted now.

I still have the strange lines on the cone and warping on my custom part.  I am using aquanet and the part is stuck so well to the glass that when I peal it off, most of the brim stays stuck to the glass.  The face of the custom part is looking much better now.

http://s7.postimg.org/xnlpvs1gr/image.jpg

Plastic Scribbler 2100

54

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

A couple of things worth noting...
You mentioned that you set your multiplier to achieve .42mm wall thickness.  It looks like (from plastic scribbler site) that you have a .40 nozzle and there for should be looking for a wall thickness of .48.  I am only mentioning this as it would lead me to believe (Since your prints are getting better) that perhaps reducing it is masking some other issues.

So... The first issue I see in those prints is backlash or perhaps some wobble in the extruder assembly.  Wobble is usually rather simple to remedy.  I am not familiar with your particular printer so I can't point you in a particular direction.  Belts are easy enough to tighten so maybe that's part of the problem.
It also appears that you may not have random start points selected in your Slic3r profile.

Previously you had mentioned layer heights not being set to round numbers such as .3  You may want to look into some calibration of your Z-axis.  Same as you did for E:  just call for a certain amount of travel and measure then adjust in EEPROM.
Often times an odd layer height number is derived based on the number of steps from your motor and the particular thread pitch of the Z-axis as a stepper motor can not make a partial step it will round to the closest step.  With short prints this will have little to no effect but with taller prints can create a layer separation issue every so many layers.
Does that make sense?

Printit Industries Model 8.10 fully enclosed CoreXY, Chamber heat
3-SD3's & a Workbench all fully enclosed, RH-Slic3r Win7pro, E3D V6, Volcano & Cyclops Hot End
SSR/500W AC Heated Glass Bed, Linear bearings on SS rods. Direct Drive Y-axis, BulldogXL
Thanks to all for your contributions

55

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

I see what you are saying.  I should be .40 x 1.2 and be printing at .48.  I was getting .49 so I wasn't far off before I made the change.

Regarding the layer heights- I had installed the software from the plastic scribbler website and found that they were using 'odd numbers' for layer heights.  I then installed the software that came in the printer box, and now the  print heights are .1,.2,.3. 

So I need to get my layer height back to .48, look for wobble issues on the extruder, check Z travel and do more testing.

Plastic Scribbler 2100

56

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

I have put everything back to the stock settings and leveled the bed and adjusted the z axis again.  The print head appears level with the bed and wth a spirit level, the bed is level in x and y as is the print head.  I don't see anything loose.  The belts seem tight, the screw drives on the z access look smooth.   Test prints appear to have the correct wall thicknesses.

I probably don't know what to look for.  The point .2mm prints look sloppy in the areas where the layers start and stop.  The .1mm prints are sloppy on the bottom and pretty much perfect on the top.  Is that a clue?


http://s16.postimg.org/7t3b8qqfp/cones.jpg
hosting image

Plastic Scribbler 2100

57

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

What pitch thread is the Z-axis?
It looks as though you have some moisture in your filament.
You may consider increasing retraction speed and length slightly as well.

Printit Industries Model 8.10 fully enclosed CoreXY, Chamber heat
3-SD3's & a Workbench all fully enclosed, RH-Slic3r Win7pro, E3D V6, Volcano & Cyclops Hot End
SSR/500W AC Heated Glass Bed, Linear bearings on SS rods. Direct Drive Y-axis, BulldogXL
Thanks to all for your contributions

58

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

I'm not sure I understand the question. Are you asking for the gap between from the top of one thread to the next thread?  It looks like 2mm.

For moisture, do you put the spool in the oven or something?  I'm not sure of the procedure.  Here's a picture of the first layer where the first layer is set to .2mm.  There seems to be an error in the upper left corner where abs was laid down diagonally where there shouldn't have been printing.  There also appears to be an error on the bottom right. 

Retraction problems?  Heat problem?  (or completely normal) I printed at 240, anything higher and the ABS oozes out even when nothing is printing.

http://s1.postimg.org/xlwbweb33/1_Layer2mm.jpg
image uploading site

Plastic Scribbler 2100

59

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Those are some pretty thin extrusions, what changed?
I was asking what is the z-rod pitch?  For every revolution you get how much travel?

Printit Industries Model 8.10 fully enclosed CoreXY, Chamber heat
3-SD3's & a Workbench all fully enclosed, RH-Slic3r Win7pro, E3D V6, Volcano & Cyclops Hot End
SSR/500W AC Heated Glass Bed, Linear bearings on SS rods. Direct Drive Y-axis, BulldogXL
Thanks to all for your contributions

60

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Looks like moisture is in the filament to me too.  Instructions using an oven can be found on the web to bake the moisture out of the filament, but i've never tried it.  I would keep my flament stored in a sealed container with desiccant such as damp rid when not in use though.   I've heard of people melting the spool holders when baking the filament so be careful!     

Something else worth mentioning is to take the mean of your actual filament diameter and use that in slic3r.  Just measure the filament in several places 10-20 and take the average.  If the filament isn't consistent it maybe extruding too much plastic in areas and then going away in other areas.  That's one of the problems with cheap filament.

Hope this helps.

61 (edited by stevea3342 2014-10-31 15:16:19)

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

I'll pursue the filament moisture issue.  The thing is, the prints fail consistently in the same area.  The manufacturer asked me to print a 100mm high object so they can check the steps per mm.  They also said that the nozzle diameter should be .4, but can vary from .35-.40 so they would like me to try different nozzle diameters.   I haven't tried to print lower than 240c and suspect that I am still printing too hot, too much flow.

My filament does vary from 1.68-1.78 and is set to 1.73, but I think I could be more accurate.

For anyone considering Plastic Scribbler, they have been very helpful on the tech support side and answer emails quickly.  I'm sure the printer can be 'fixed' with software and/or screw driver.  I doubt there is anything wrong with the printer build.

Plastic Scribbler 2100

62

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

One more thing I wanted to mention in regards to warping.    You might find that lowering the first layer speed will create a nicer bond to the glass and decrease the warping.   Also,  a lower infill  helps decrease warp if the part doesn't need to be strong.   

There are also option in slic3r to increase brim size and skirt height which might help with warping issues too.

63

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Looking at printers myself, and seriously considering a scribbler now. It's been a couple weeks since the last post, so I'm curious, were you able to get yours printing well?

64

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Hi.  The printer is great on .2 and .3mm layer heights.   There's no warping and I don't need to do anything special to get the model to stick to the bed and don't even need to print brims.  The problem is on the .1 layer height settings.  Depending on the model, the warping is horrible and I have to turn down the extrusion rate to prevent messy printing.  But at this .1 extrusion rate, the walls are printing too thin.

These were both printed at .2mm layer height and I am pleased with the way they printed.  Considering the vase was 200mm high, it shows that the printer maintained precision pretty well up the Z axis.  There is a bit of a rough spot in the center of the picture that I can't explain.

So .2 and .3 are great, perhaps .1mm is just beyond my skills or beyond the printer.

http://s10.postimg.org/4rbffrdf9/ex1.jpg

Plastic Scribbler 2100

65 (edited by GamerDarling 2014-11-12 14:42:01)

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

It's great to see it pass the torture test! Is there any chance of another shot of the torture test, specifically the bridge? 

The vase also looks awesome...It's probably got a lot to do with the material as well, but on that vase there's several areas where I don't even see the grain of the layers. Are you still using a print temp above 230 C?

66

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

This was printed with no supports with brim.  I think I was printing at 235 (ABS).  I should be able to bring the heat level down, but the flow rate at 235 with a .95 extrusion rate seems to be working well.  IMaybe it will print at 220 or 225 with a '1' extrusion rate but my filament seems to work better at a higher temp.  I'm using hatchbox but I have a spool of SainSmart that I want to try as well.

http://s4.postimg.org/9m1hr34jt/20141112_094731.jpg

http://s29.postimg.org/a64j0e0zn/20141112_094748.jpg

http://s18.postimg.org/57t3jvu11/20141112_094800.jpg

Let me know if I can be of any help.

Plastic Scribbler 2100

67

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

this is to complicated for me to understand. but i want to know more about 3D printing.

68

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Soliforum is a good place to ask questions.

Plastic Scribbler 2100

69

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

stevea3342 wrote:

...
My filament does vary from 1.68-1.78 and is set to 1.73, but I think I could be more accurate.
...

-    That's a bit heavy of a fluctuation, which can make tuning difficult. Another aspect to check is its circularity, this also has to be taken into consideration when setting the filament diameter variable. If your curious about my methods I wrote a short article detailing them.

My Printing Methods: goc3d.blogspot.com/2014/11/3d-printing-tips-strength-accuracy.html

stevea3342 wrote:

... 
I'm using hatchbox but I have a spool of SainSmart that I want to try as well.
...

-    When you switch over to the SainSmart I would be curious to hear about your results. I was using their PLA and wasn't having the greatest quality with it.

Tip: If this is going to be your first filament change, save out your 'hatchbox' settings/configs. When changing between suppliers and some colors you'll more than likely have to re-tweak the settings for each.

My Filament Experiences: goc3d.blogspot.com/2014/11/3d-printing-filament-basic-review.html

70

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Thanks for the suggestions. I haven't swapped filament yet but will share my experience once I do.

Plastic Scribbler 2100

71

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Here is some more food for thought.
http://www.3dhubs.com/best-3d-printer-guide

SD2 - Glass Bed, Fans on PCB and Y motor, Custom enclosure
Slicer - Simplify3D

72

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

Stevea3342, thank you for starting this thread. I have found it very helpful and hope to write a review of my experiences with plastic scribbler in the future.

73

Re: Looking for my first 3d printer

teresa005 wrote:

this is to complicated for me to understand. but i want to know more about 3D printing.

What made you not understand about 3D printing.? You may ask any questions about what you want to know, and later we the members here who know the answer to mean you'll try to answer it, because that's what we are in the forum, and help one another. Come on do not be shy to ask, cheers smile

Finally, i have thermal printer, it's make me happy smile