1

Topic: Solidoodle Forum

Is this forum dedicated mostly to Solidoodle issues or is it for 3D printing in general largely? If I could I'd love to create a sticky for reviewing filaments and other parts so everyone can give their input in a more tabulated way instead of just in a particular context throughout the forums.

2

Re: Solidoodle Forum

It is the #2 Google hit for "3D Printing Forums" so I don't see the harm in branching out.  I think that is why we are starting to see more posters come by with general "What printer should I buy" questions.  So much of what we talk about applies to the hobby in general anyway.  That is why I like to check in on the Makerbot group and other printer forums, sometimes there are things to learn there that apply to the Solidoodle.

3 (edited by DePartedPrinter 2013-09-17 15:34:59)

Re: Solidoodle Forum

i asked for filament reviews almost a year ago... http://www.soliforum.com/topic/650/filament-reviews/

SD2 with E3D, SD Press, Form 1+
Filastruder
NYLON (taulman): http://www.soliforum.com/topic/466/nylon/

4

Re: Solidoodle Forum

How does one create a sticky, and how does one gather input from other users? maybe using survey monkey or something? I could start it off with my input on the filaments I've used. I am not sure if filaments behave that much differently with different printers, but so far I can only conclude that SD filament works well with common colors like blue, red, white, and green, and so far Octave is a bit runny and has shreded a bit more than the SD filament, which only means I should clean the gears every other print (which for $10 less than SD could be worth it). Also I have been weighing the rolls full and empty so I know how much I actually get when I order from various companies. I worry it is ultimately all from China anyway, but there are some apparent differences between them. lol. Maybe people could review even the width of the roll itself. I personally prefered the wide roles because the filament was wrapped better and didn't yank the Y carriage when it snagged. How can I start building a sticky? I was thinking mostly in terms of tables of data, and some reviews in ones own words.

5

Re: Solidoodle Forum

Users can't stick topics, only moderators (Brad/Lawsy/IanJohnson).

Your best bet is to make a post in the thread DeParted linked aggregating all of the info, or a wiki page. Once there is a good central location with *quality* information, PM a moderator and ask them to stick it.

6

Re: Solidoodle Forum

A page in the wiki is probably best for consolidating information like that, since threads always get cluttered up with discussion

7

Re: Solidoodle Forum

IanJohnson wrote:

A page in the wiki is probably best for consolidating information like that, since threads always get cluttered up with discussion

+1

Once the wiki page is built up we can sticky a thread pointing to it.

8

Re: Solidoodle Forum

How do I create a wiki page? How do I get others to contribute their experiences to it?

9

Re: Solidoodle Forum

I couldn't even find out how to change a page on wikipedia when I knew it was completely wrong. lol.

10

Re: Solidoodle Forum

We are open to discussion of all 3d printers here, not just the solidoodle. If a specific printer gets enough attention, I have no problem making a dedicated section for it. We started off as a solidoodle forum, but now we are open to everything.